Hydrogen Reformer Tubes Ruptured during Startup
A hydrogen reformer furnace at a refinery was shutdown for maintenance to remove and cap the inlet and outlet headers of some radiant tubes that had previously developed hot spots and been isolated by externally pinching them off at the inlet. A decision was made to leave steam in the steam-generating circuit during this maintenance operation to prevent freezing. After maintenance was complete, the startup procedure required the furnace to be first heated up to 350°C (662°F) prior to introducing 4136 kPa (600 psig) steam into the radiant tubes. Just after the 4136 kPa (600 psig) startup steam was introduced into the reformer furnace inlet, the control room alarm journal reported an extreme positive pressure spike at the same time a single loud bang was reported by the operations personnel on the furnace structure. An emergency shutdown of the furnace was initiated and the startup aborted. At the time of the incident, there were seven people on the furnace. Four were operations staff and three were maintenance personnel. One serious injury was sustained to an operator by flying shrapnel. There was no hydrogen leak or explosion related to this incident; the startup failure occurred prior to the introduction of methane for the hydrogen-generation step.
The cause of this incident was determined to be the initial steam flow picking up some remnant water and carrying it into the furnace. Under the conditions present, the water underwent an instantaneous phase change and the energy release was sufficient to rupture the hydrogen reformer furnace radiant tubes. The entire event was calculated to have taken only a few milliseconds, but involved extremely high-energy release rates. This high-energy impulse caused the simultaneous rupture of five tubes with sufficient force to eject portions of the tubes out through the roof of the furnace as shrapnel. All of the failures occurred near the inlet of the tubes in the headspace above the catalyst, and the five tubes were clustered toward the center of the furnace in four rows. Approximately 41 additional radiant tubes were destroyed as a result of impacts from ejected tube segments and the subsequent pressure wave. Extensive damage to the refractory also occurred. As a result, the furnace internal structure was condemned and a complete re-tubing was required. Broken light fixtures, insulation, and walkway gratings damaged by shrapnel impacts were found above the furnace and on a west-side furnace platform.
More details about this incident can be found in the attached files. The background and details text file includes appropriate references to the attached figures and photos.
