Skip to main content

Lessons Learned

Lessons Learned

CHECK OUT OUR MOST RELEVANT INCIDENT LISTINGS!

Disclaimer: The Lessons Learned Database includes the incidents that were voluntarily submitted. The database is not a comprehensive source for all incidents that have occurred.

Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: No
Ignition: No
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Vessel
Probable Cause: Human Error
When Incident Discovered: During Inspection
Lessons Learned:

Extra caution should be taken working around elevated pressure or low-temperature fluids and storage. Values should be checked and then verified by a second party, if possible.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Compressor, Valve
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:

All valves and connectors should be clearly labeled to minimize chances for mis-connection. All technicians must be trained on proper procedures for both taking systems offline and bringing them back online.

Valves for compressed hydrogen gas service are discussed in the Hydrogen Safety Best Practices Manual.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics: High Pressure (> 100 bar)
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Probable Cause: Design Flaw
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

First, it appears that the system may not have been vented properly. CGA G-5.5 should be used for determining safe locations based on the variables of the specific setup. Also, if the compressor was tied to a storage system, a backflow prevention device may have limited the amount of gas that was released. Finally, it appears that equipment was left in place from previous activities. Such equipment should be evaluated to make sure that it is appropriate and safe for use in new processes.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Minor Injury, Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:

Because of the near invisibility of a hydrogen flame in daylight and hydrogen's extremely low ignition coefficient, if a known leak is present (e.g., an audible hissing), ignition should always be presumed. The primary cause of this incident derives from the technician improperly performing hot work in the vicinity of a charged flammable gas line. Given the location of the flammable gas line, an alternative to performing hot work or relocating the hot work should have been considered. If such work was necessary at this location, it should have been performed only after the gas supply was verified closed (along with a lock and tag). Also, if this latter option was chosen, then the system should be checked for leaks prior to turning the gas back on.

Email (Primary):
Description
Contributing Factors: Human Error
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Near-Miss
Leak: No
Ignition: No
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Probable Cause: Design Flaw
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

The tube was 403 stainless steel, which is subject to hydrogen embrittlement. It is requested that all gauges that have bourdon tubes be replaced with 303 stainless steel.

A web-based resource developed by Sandia National Laboratories to provide data on hydrogen embrittlement of various materials is available at Technical Reference for Hydrogen Compatibility of Materials.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Probable Cause: Design Flaw
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

The charging characteristics of a battery vary with the condition of the battery and are proportional to the ampere-hour capacity of the battery. During charging, when a battery is close to being fully charged, hydrogen and oxygen both offgas in a flammable mixture. Emergency battery containers require adequate ventilation for all operations, or the battery box should be designed to:

  • Eliminate all sparking devices
  • Ventilate during charging operations,
  • Provide inert gas purge and pressurization methods, and
  • Provide adequate pressure relief.

Adequate ventilation of battery charging facilities is addressed in the Lessons Learned Corner on this website.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

It is characteristic of silver/zinc batteries to outgas both hydrogen and oxygen for several hours after discharge. Also, in the future, the battery should be properly secured inside the container.

Email (Primary):
Description
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Near-Miss
Leak: No
Ignition: No
Ignition Source:
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Refueling operations need to be conducted in a careful and attentive manner, and operators need to be aware of the potential consequences of their actions.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics: High Pressure (> 100 bar)
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Valve, Venting System
When Incident Discovered: During Inspection
Lessons Learned:

The site needs to implement a good Operational and Readiness Inspection procedure. System inspection deficiencies need to be identified, and (if possible) reviewed by a second party before future tests are conducted. This inspection could include the following:


  • Check all relief valve set points
  • Check potential design flaws
  • Check all other relevant operational characteristics

A proper vent system design is as important as the relief valve itself. A vent system should be able to operate with no consequence at all. Proper facility design and venting to a safe location would have made this a near-miss instead of an incident.

Email (Primary):
Description
Contributing Factors: Human Error, Situational Awareness
Damage and Injuries: None
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: No
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Dewar
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:

Proper bolt identification can prevent similar occurrences in the future. This can be achieved by simply painting the critical bolt heads a certain color (or by purchasing bolts with painted bolt heads). An explanation form should then be clearly posted, which indicates which bolts are critical, and which aren't. This information should then be disseminated to all of the relevant technicians.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Contributing Factors: Human Error, Individual Action
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Uncertain
Ignition: No
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Vessel, Valve
When Incident Discovered: During Inspection
Lessons Learned:

Extra caution should be taken when working around elevated pressure storage tanks. Pressure relief valve settings should be checked and then verified by a second party if possible. Proper procedures need to be followed at all times.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:
  • Facilities housing battery charging systems need to ensure the ventilation systems are operational, and delivering enough outdoor air to properly ventilate the enclosure.
  • Operators need to be aware of safe practices and proper battery charging instructions for the nickel cadmium batteries they work on. This information needs to be disseminated to all of the technicians working on the batteries and battery charging systems.

Adequate ventilation of battery charging facilities is addressed in the Lessons Learned Corner on this website.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Equipment: Gasket
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Normally hydrogen fires are not extinguished until the supply of hydrogen has been shut off due to the danger of re-ignition and explosion. During a gas leak/fire, it is important to shut off the source of the hydrogen if it is safe to do so. If the leak cannot be stopped, the danger of a fire (or an explosion if the unburned hydrogen gas is leaking into a poorly ventilated confined space) would be very high. If a leak cannot be stopped, fire extinguishing is impossible and only prevention of fire spreading is possible. It is also difficult to detect a gas leak from thermally insulated piping at an early stage.

Countermeasures which were employed to prevent future occurrences include:

  • Improving management of construction at turnaround to prevent improper gasket installations.
  • To detect gas leaks in piping systems covered with thermal insulation, inspection windows were installed in the insulation and gas leak checks were strengthened.
Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Lessons Learned The site initiated the establishment of a field patrol and strengthened their onsite monitoring of mechanical equipment during a plant-wide temperature rise.

  • Quantitative control of tightening torque on bolts should be carefully executed at all high-temperature and high-pressure plants.
  • A plant must pay close attention to both the chemical impacts and the mechanical impacts of an unexpected temperature rise during start-up operations.

Several factors are important for flange use in applications of this type. Bolting patterns/torque order need to be considered in engineering, training, stewardship, and maintenance aspects of the specific operations. Cold bolt torque requirements should be developed so hot bolting is not required or relied upon for start-up. Flange stress from an increased or decreased operating temperature needs to always be checked. Substantial industry knowledge and practice exist for flange use to ensure that such operations are conducted safely.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: None
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Equipment: Valve, Gasket
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Lessons Learned
Construction errors are difficult to detect once construction is complete. It is important to develop and use a systematic oversight process for minimizing construction errors during the construction process.

Countermeasures

  • Thorough control of component parts during the construction process is required.
  • Bolts should be tightened equally and fully.
  • A new support for distributing the weight of piping is installed.
  • Thoroughness of checks after construction is going to be initiated.

Additional discussion about working with reactive metal-hydride materials in the laboratory can be found in the Lessons Learned Corner on this website and in the Hydrogen Safety Best Practices Manual.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Although a functional fire protection system would have helped to extinguish the fire, a properly installed hydrogen detection system, coupled with a properly designed ventilation system, could have prevented the incident altogether.

Hydrogen rises twice as fast as helium, at a speed of 45 mph. Therefore, unless a roof or some other structure contains the rising gas, the laws of physics prevent hydrogen from lingering near its point of production. It is unclear weather the room's ventilation system wasn't functioning properly, or if it wasn't designed properly; but in either case, battery charging facilities need to consult experienced engineering firms on proper location and design of hydrogen detection and exhaust systems. On-site Standard Operating Procedures also need to mandate periodic functional/operational tests.

Adequate ventilation of battery charging facilities is addressed in the Lessons Learned Corner on this website.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics: High Pressure (> 100 bar)
Damage and Injuries: Human Life, Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source:
Equipment:
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

Routine maintenance activities on pressurized hydrogen systems should be conducted per written design specifications. The procedures should provide detailed oversight regarding bolt, nut and fitting replacements or repairs. A formal review process should be required to ensure that the maintenance was performed according to the written specifications, and that the hydrogen system will continue to function as designed until the next scheduled maintenance activity.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Human Life, Minor Injury, Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source: Open Flame
Setting: Laboratory
When Incident Discovered: During Operations
Lessons Learned:

This incident emphasizes the need for proper gas detection and ventilation systems, as well as fire suppression systems, in laboratories using and storing hydrogen. This is especially true when open flame burners are in close proximity. Experienced consultants/engineers should be involved in the design of gas detection and ventilation systems before hydrogen cylinders are employed in any laboratory. Laboratories also need to develop a Standard Operating Procedure, requiring periodic maintenance on hydrogen systems to check fittings, valves, and all critical components to ensure proper functionality at all times.

Email (Primary):
Description
Characteristics:
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Yes
Ignition Source: Friction From the High-Velocity Gas Flow
Setting: Refinery
Probable Cause: Inadequate Maintenance
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:

Hazards should be eliminated to the extent possible rather than depending on workers to follow an operations manual.

Potassium carbonate draw-off operations should be improved, and the operations manual should be revised. The manual should be reviewed by workers before maintenance activities are started. Training on mandatory compliance with the operations manual should be carried out for all staff involved in hydrogen plant operations and maintenance.

Email (Primary):
Description
Damage and Injuries: Property Damage
Incident Date:
Severity: Incident
Leak: Yes
Ignition: Uncertain
Ignition Source:
Setting: Laboratory
Equipment: Vessel, Valve
Probable Cause: Inadequate Maintenance
When Incident Discovered: During Maintenance
Lessons Learned:

Fail-safe position of control valves in supply lines must be set correctly to prevent damage to pressure vessels.

Recommendation

Set all valves for fail safe operation (open or closed) according to needs before installation in pressure or vacuum systems.

Email (Primary):