Fire on the pre-heater of a desulphurisation unit
A tube ruptured in the charge heater ('fired heater') of a desulphurisation reactor due to a blockage caused by accelerated coking. Flames spread over an area of some 100 feet outward from the bottom of the heater and more than 50 feet out from the stack. Burner connections were blown loose adding to the fire at the base of the heater. Within minutes operators reacted to shut down and block in feed, hydrogen make-up and product streams, to isolate fuel at battery limits and to initiate steps to depressurise the unit. Fire control forces were set up and began applying cooling water to surrounding equipment and on the furnace skin and stack. Special attention was given to the reactor and nearby exchangers. With all systems secured and isolated, the fire was allowed to burn itself out, which took approximately 30 minutes. The failure was caused by accelerated coking in the furnace tubes because of insufficient hydrogen recycle coupled with severe flow imbalance. As the system (hydrogen supply was depleted and the heater continued to be fired harder, the coking risk problem was worsened. Heater pass temperatures became unstable, but the operators’ attention was focussed entirely on an attempt to improve mechanical flow balance using the pass inlet gate valves.

The INTIATING CAUSE was the rupture of one or more tubes of a fire heater due to over-heating, casued by los feed flow and accelerated coking. SEQUENCE of CAUSES On the day of the incident a recycle (and make-up) compressor was shut down due to hot valves. This resulted in a 3-folded reduction of the recycle gas rate. The operators did not make any attempt to compensate the feed rate, because (1) the then current operating practice did not call for maintaining a minimum hydrogen/hydrocarbons ratio and because (2) the operators knew from experience that one compressor fully loaded was sufficient. What they did not recognise, however, was that this compressor was operating at less than 50% of its normal capacity. ROOT CAUSE: inadequate training and lack of process monitoring devices.