Fire in a pharmaceutical plant
The accident occurred in a plant producing synthesised active ingredients for the pharmaceutical industry. An explosion and a fire occurred in one of the workshops of the plant. The chemical reaction is the reduction of an imide to an amine in anhydrous medium in presence catalysts. The reaction is performed in an ether solution and the reactor is nitrogen purged. Hydrogen is one of the reaction products. The imide is introduced in the reactor via a flexible pipe connected with a mobile pneumatic dosing pump. The operating procedure specifies that the reaction must be performed for at least 8 hours and that the temperature of the reaction medium must not exceed 65°C. On the day of the incident, the operation started 30 min before shift end. 15 minutes later the temperature threshold was reached - the operators started to cool the reactor to maintain the temperature around 65°C. Despite the action, the reaction ran away: the temperature and the pressure rose in the vessel. The operator nearest to the reactor smelled an unpleasant odour. Through the sight glass he saw a glow preceding the explosion. Employees at 15 m distance perceive a blow. A flame projected through the workshop, other flames shot out from a joint and other reactor connections. Employees outside the building perceived a blow just before the explosion. A flame several metres high was visible for some seconds at the exit of a chimney connected with the reactor rupture disc (calibrated at 0. 5 bar) that burst, allowing the decompression of the reactor.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITATING CAUSE was the production of significant quantities of hydrogen formed by the runaway reaction and not absorbed by the reaction medium. The ignition of the gas may have been caused by static electricity in the reactor, a hot spot or the presence of diborane and water traces. The equipment was essentially operated manually and required physical presence, in absence of remote control of the process. Part of the production process was not controlled by written instructions but let to the experience of the operators, among which there was a newcomer. In addition, the unit lacked the diagnostics required to monitor and control the reaction (flow metres, pressure gauges) and therefore also the automatic safety measures to prevent escalation and mitigate consequences. The ROOT CAUSE was absence of a safety design and risk assessment , combined with failure to guarantee the correct operators knowledge.
