Skip to main content

Fire on a LH2 tank under maintenance (328)

This data is from the European Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents database HIAD 2.1, European Commission, Joint Research Centre.

Fire on a LH2 tank under maintenance

The event occurred when attempting to replace a rupture disk in a LH2 vessel. Hydrogen gas was released and ignited. In fighting the fire, liquid nitrogen was sprayed onto a second LH2 vessel located nearby, what resulted in the cracking of the outer mild steel vacuum jacket. The loss of the vacuum caused a rapid increase in pressure and rupture of the burst disk of the second vessel. H2 boiled off and was burned in the fire. [Ordin, NASA (1974)]

Record Quality Indicator
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments

When rupture disk was being replaced, the vessel was still loaded with LH2 , without purging gas. The H2-air mixture was probably ignited by static discharges. This suggest as ROOT CAUSE a failure in following the procedure. Rupture of the second vessel burst disk was caused by the low temperature exposure of the mild steel vacuum jacket. This time an emergency procedure failed, or the choice of the tank materials was wrong.

Facility Information
Application Type
Application
Aerospace
Specific Application Supply Chain Stage
Components Involved

burst disk, LH2 vessels

Storage/Process Medium
Location Type
Operational Condition
Pre-event Summary

A failed burst disk on the LH2 vessel was being replaced.

Consequences
Number of Injured Persons
0
Number of Fatalities
0
Environmental Damage
0
Lessons Learned

The source describing this event (Ordin, NASA) did not provide all details necessary to understand in- depth what happened. (1) At the start of this event, there is the action aiming at replacing a burst disk which had opened. Why this action was performed without inert gas protection is not explained. It is however important to notice, as explained by H2TOOLS, that liquid hydrogen storage systems are usually, or should be equipped with two independent pressure relief systems, with the possibility to switch between the two. Operators can then keep one in function and isolate the other to execute repair or maintenance works without the risk of hydrogen release. (2) Moreover, the source does not explain the decision to use liquid nitrogen to fight the fire. Was it the only fire suppression system on the site? Was it to extinguish the fire, or to keep cold neighbouring liquid hydrogen vessels? This last option is the most probable, because the use of liquid nitrogen to extinguish a hydrogen fire has demonstrated ineffective. Usually, under these conditions, the hydrogen is left releasing till emptying the vessel. On top of that, solid nitrogen could even have blocked the venting by freezing in contact with colder hydrogen, creating the condition for a BLEVE (boiling liquid evaporating explosion), as it happened in another case when water was used fight the over-pressurisation of a vessel (HIAD_609). (3) The temperature of the liquid nitrogen induced local thermal-mechanical stresses in the external shell of the neighbouring vessel, due to the contraction of the steel. If used intensively on the first vessel, it would have created on it the same condition for cracking.

Event Nature
Release Type
Release Substance
H2 100%
Hydrogen Release Concentration (%)
0.00
Ignition Source
References
References

Mishap no 38 in P. L. Ordin, Review of hydrogen accidents and incidents in NASA operations, 1974, NASA TM X-71565 https://ntrs. nasa. gov/citations/19740020344

Lowesmith et al. , Safety issues of the liquefaction, storage and transportation of liquid hydrogen: An analysis of incidents and HAZIDS, Int. J. Hydrogen energy (2014) https://doi. org/10. 1016/j. ijhydene. 2014. 08. 002

Hankinson and Lowesmith, Qualitative Risk Assessment of Hydrogen Liquefaction, Storage and Transportation, FCH JU project IDEALHY, Deliverable 3. 10 (2013) confidential (accessed October 2025)

Hankinson and Lowesmith, HAZIDs for Hydrogen Liquefaction, Storage and Transportation , FCH JU project IDEALHY, Deliverable 3. 11 (2013) https://www. idealhy. eu/uploads/documents/IDEALHY_D3-10%20HAZIDs_Liquefaction_Storage_Transportation_Summary_web. pdf (Only summary publicly available, accessed October 2025)

Also H2TOOLS has uploaded this NASA mishap https://h2tools. org/lessons/liquid-hydrogen-tank-incident-leads-second-incident (accessed dec 2024)