Syngas fire in a ammonia plant
The incident occurred at the ammonia synthesis unit of a production plant of fertilizers (Seveso III upper tier), during the operation of start-up. The unit was restarting, when a pipe carrying syngas (73% hydrogen, pressure 135 bar and 390°C) opened completely at a weld joining a section of vertical pipe and a connecting elbow with a horizontal pipe. The released gas ignited, due to sparks produced by the projection of fixing parts of the pipe due to the internal pressure. The burning rate of the gas cloud increased explosively, producing a deflagration, a pressure wave and a flame front that damaged the thermal insulation of other pipes near leak and generated a thermal radiative field. After the explosion, the fire continued fed by the continuous release of the gas. The Ammonia plant was shut down immediately, the synthesis loop was depressurised and inertised with nitrogen. The plant and local firefighters were able to extinguish the fire in two hours.

The INITIATING CAUSE was the opening at a weld of a pipe carrying syngas. For the ROOT CAUSES, the post-accident investigation was only able propose a list of possible material- and design-related factors: 1) Mechanical vibrations of the synthesis column generated by operation at high temperatures and pressures (about 140 bar). 2) Degradation to the mechanical properties of pipe materials due hydrogen attack. 3) Change in the material properties of the weld due to high temperature (a clean separation of the two welded pipe sections was found) 4) The rupture occurred at the welding between two materials with different compositions and mechanical properties (stress caused differential dilatation). 5) Temperature transients during plant startup and ammonia reactor heating. 6) The design prescribed a minimal distance between the weld and the heated components, to avoid too high temperature on the weld, It is possible that this safety distance was not large enough. The list suggest a ROOT CAUSE related to the lack of material control, possible design shortcoming and lack of effective inspection/monitoring procedures & methods.