Paper pulp tank explosion
In a paper plant, an explosion occurs in a paper pulp tank while 2 workers were carrying out pipes cutting with a grinder on the roof of the tank. Detailed analysis of the event was performed by two independent experts. The paper pulp stored under certain conditions can ferment and produce hydrogen. The final expert report establishes the explosion process as follows: - The pulp stored in the tank released hydrogen at a rate such that the LFL (lower flammability limit) could be reached within a few hours. - Hydrogen mixed with the air in the tank top to formed an exploice atmosphere. - The ignition source of the mixture was an incandescent particle produced during cutting with grinder of the pipe connected to the upper gaseous part of the tank. - The overpressure developed by the explosion led to the rupture of the tower roof at the level of the connection welding with the cylindrical flange. [ARIA]
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITATING CAUSE was the creation of a flammable mixture in the surrounding of the tank due to leak, ignited by a spark of the pressure gauge, possibly assisted by static electricity shock. All filling operations, including their controls, were performed manually. Except for a measure of the internal tank total pressure by means of a portable pressure gauge, no other monitoring system was used, despite the specific hazards related to handling hydrogen and oxygen. In particularly, no flammable gas detector is mentioned having been used. Moreover, leak tests after assembly had not been performed at the nominal (rated) tank pressure, but at less than 2/3 of it. The ROOT CAUSE was related to lack of proper risk assessment, lack of preventing and mitigating safety systems, and lack of duly supervision by university management of the activities if a visiting fellow.
