Natural gas pipeline failure due to hydrogen attack
[NOTE of the EVENT VALIDATOR: this is a natural gas event, related to the NG supply chain. It may be however of interest for hydrogen-NG mixture transportation in pipeline. ] A 30-inch natural gas transmission pipeline ruptured, releasing about 101. 5 million cubic feet of natural gas, which ignited. The fire fighters were almost immediately on site, 3 hours later all fire suppression activities had concluded. The pipeline failed by a combination of a manufacturing defect, a degraded coating and ineffective cathodic protection, all resulting in hydrogen-induced cracking at the outer surface of the pipeline. The accident resulted in 1 fatality, 6 injuries, and the evacuation of over 75 people. Five residences were destroyed by resulting structure fires, and an additional 14 were damaged. A nearby railroad track was also damaged, and over 30 acres of land were burned.

The INITIATING cause was the failure of a natural gas pipeline due to hydrogen cracking at a weak spot. The NTSB investigation identified the root cause in shortcoming of the company integrity management program. It did not accurately assess the condition of the pipeline and/or estimate the risk from combined threats. The company underestimated the risk posed by hard spots because its processes and procedures were inconsistent with PHMSA guidance and industry knowledge of hard spot threat interaction. In details, the contributing causes were: (1) Incomplete evaluation of the risks caused by a change of gas flow direction; (2) Limitations in data analysis related to in-line inspection tool usage; (3) Incomplete assessment of threats and threat interactions; (4) Missed opportunities in training and requalification practices.