Hydrogen leak delaying launch of a space rocket
The event occurred during the fuelling process of the primary fuel tank of the core stage of a moon rocket. The initial slow-filling phase was terminated, and personnel had just started the fast-filling phase when a leak was detected on a quick-disconnect fitting of the liquid hydrogen line into the tank. Hydrogen was leaking into the purge can, which is a housing covering the quick disconnect fitting, part of the tail service mast umbilicals. The leak was exceeding the concentration limit of 4%, set by flammability risks, by a factor of two or three. Engineers made several attempts to reseat the fitting on-site and on-launch, by allowing it to warm up and replacing the seal, or by closing the fuelling valve and drain it, then increasing pressure on the ground transfer line using helium to force the fitting back into place. Eventually, the launch on 3rd of September had to be postponed. In the following days, engineers troubleshooted the leak. During the cryogenic tests, the 21st September, already during the slow-filling phase a leak at the same location was detected. The connection was again warmed up and refixed, and the filling operation continued at lower pressure than before. This time the hydrogen concentration in the housing remained under the allowed limit, and the refuelling could continue up to full fill and the pressurisation tests. During the next launch attempt, the 15th of November, the fast-fuelling phase was successfully completed, but a valve at the base of the mobile launcher, used to replenish the core stage with hydrogen, showed a leak above safety limits. The hydrogen flow was stopped, and a team of engineers had to go to access the pad and tighten several bolts to troubleshoot a valve. The rocket lifted off one day later.

The INITATING CAUSE was a hydrogen leak from a liquid hydrogen connection, above the allowed maximal concentration in air. One possible reason of the loss of confinement capacity of the connection could have been an error of over-pressurisation of the liquid hydrogen line of the quick-disconnect interface, which may have damaged a seal. During the early phase of hydrogen transfer operations called chill-down, aiming at cooling down the lines and propulsion system prior to flowing liquid hydrogen, an inadvertent command was sent that temporarily raised the pressure in the system. A second explanation of the leak could have been a small indentation on the eight-inch-diameter liquid hydrogen seal, found during the post-mortem examination of the seal. These sources do not identify with certainty a ROOT CAUSE. From the suggested leak explanations, it derive that one root cause factor could have been the cryogenic procedure.