Skip to main content

Fire in a Steam-Methane Reformer reactor of a refinery (772)

This data is from the European Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents database HIAD 2.1, European Commission, Joint Research Centre.

Fire in a Steam-Methane Reformer reactor of a refinery

The accident happened in a refinery unit, constructed ten years before. A pigtail ruptured in a steam reformer for the production of hydrogen, and caused a major fire, which destroyed most of the tubes (54) in one quadrant of the large steam-methane reformer furnace. No personnel was hurt. Main causes were bad weld quality and shortening of pigtails over the life of the plant, which significantly increased the cyclic stress at the root of the weld from thermal expansion and tube bowing. After the failure of the pigtail, the downstream hydrogen flew back into the reformer and ignited together with the hydrocarbons present there. Changes done in design and operating procedures are described in the article mentioned among the references.
Event Date
June 12, 1984
Record Quality Indicator
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITIATING CAUSE was the failure of aged pigtails at the root of the weld, due to thermal expansion and tube bowing. Main technical causes were bad weld quality and shortening of pigtails over the life of the plant, which significantly increased the cyclic stress at the root of the weld from thermal expansion and tube bowing. After the failure of one pigtail, the downstream hydrogen flew back into the reformer and ignited together with the hydrocarbons present there. Together with the original fire from one ruptured tube, this additional massive quantity of flammable material contributed to the escalation, with the rupture of the other tubes. A shortcoming was also found in the shut-down procedure. It was optimised to protect the catalysts during transient, but it resulted far too slow such a tube rupture. The ROOT CAUSE could be attributed to shortcoming in design and manufacturing.
Facility Information
Application Type
Application
Steam methane reforming
Specific Application Supply Chain Stage
Components Involved
steam reformer, pigtails
Storage/Process Medium
Storage/Process Quantity
0
Actual Pressure
3
Design Pressure
3
Location Type
Location description
DESCRIPTION OF THE SMR FURNACE The furnace was the primary reformer in hydrogen production unit supplying approximately 97% purity hydrogen to the hydrocracking reactors of the refinery. The unit had a capacity of 75 MMSCFD (approximately 0. 18 tons / day). The reformer was built as a steam methane reformer and is still known by this name today (SMR), although it has since been modified to accept butane or naphtha feed. The maximum operating temperature of the tube walls was 1720°F (955OC). Although the source does not report it, typical pressure values were in the range of 15 to 30 bar. The reformer was side-fired and had 256 catalyst tubes grouped in two cells. The outlet “pigtails” were short sections of straight Incoloy 800H pipe connecting the catalyst tubes to the sub-headers.
Operational Condition
Consequences
Number of Injured Persons
0
Number of Fatalities
0
Lessons Learned
McCoy et al. (see references) reported the following lessons learnt from the event: 1. Small design modifications executed to solve an immediate problem, can compromise the basic safety design of a whole process equipment. Sometimes, as in this case, several such changes have an additive effect. 2. Operating procedures must aim in first instance at protecting people and equipment, and only secondarily at protecting the catalysts. McCoy concluded on a pssimistinc note: "There are two general lessons to be learnt from this incident. These are lessons that have been learnt before and unfortunately, will probably have to be learnt again " At many years from this event, a more generic historical view can be concluded. Pigtails are a weak components of a reformer, and have initiated repeatedly similar accidents. However, improvement based on their whole lifetime, from material selections and metallurgy (micro-structure) to cycling behaviour up to inspections, have reduced significantly their negative effects on the reformer operation, as reported by the second article of 2014 among the references.
Event Nature
Release Type
Release Substance
H2, hydrocarbons
Hydrogen Release Concentration (%)
0.00
Ignition Source
Detonation
No
Deflagration
No
High Pressure Explosion
No
High Voltage Explosion
No
Flame Type
References
References

C. S. McCoy et al. , Major fire in a steam-methane reformer furnace, Plant/Operations Progress, 5 (1986) 165-168 https://doi. org/10. 1002/prsb. 720050310

On line Journal Nitrogen+Syngas, 330, July - August 2014 Available at: https://www. questintegrity. com/assets/PDFs/Articles-2014/Improving-reformer-pigtail-reliability_Nitrogen+Syngas2014. pdf Accessed July 2020)