Fire on a heat exchanger at a benzene manufacturing plant
The event occurred at a high-temperature heat of at a benzene manufacturing plant using a dealkylation reaction. High-pressure hydrogen leaked from a flange of the heat exchanger, during start-up The hydrogen ignited, and a fire followed. The leakage occurred for two reasons: (1) An insufficient tightening torque control performed during hot-bolting, which generated inhomogeneous force distribution among bolts. (2) A out-of-design temperature rise of the heat exchanger caused by a revamping during a turnaround shutdown. Event sequences: A turnaround shutdown of the benzene manufacturing plant had been carried out 3 months before. A gas-tightness test with real gas (hydrogen and another gas) was completed in September. The plant was started by increasing temperature and pressure During the operation, an operator at an adjoining plant found a fire at the upper part of the vertical reactor.

The INITATING CAUSE was a leak caused by loosening of the tightness of a flange, sue to inhomogeneous torque among bolts. The IGNITION SOURCE was attributed to static electricity generated at leakage. The shell-side inlet temperature had been increased from an initial value of 400°C to 420°C after a revamping aiming at energy-saving. This added an additional driver for the flange loosening, because a decrease in tightening torque was locally generated by a difference in thermal expansion between bolts made of stainless steel and the flange made of carbon stee (thermal expansion of stainless steel is greater than that of carbon steel). This suggests ROOT CAUSE components related to inadequate management of changes and shortcoming in operative procedures unable to control the tightness of the joint.