Fire at a fired heater of an hydrocracking unit
This incident occurred at the fired heater of a non-further specified reactor of a refinery (probably a hydro-desulphurisation unit). A tube of the fired box failed releasing a mixture of hydrogen and hydrocarbons into the firebox. The mixture consisted in approximately 51,000 pounds of diesel, 160 pounds of hydrogen and 560 pounds of methane. It was ignited by the burners, resulting in a large fire involving other part of the unit. The reason for the failure of the tube was overheating possibly in combination of creep. On the day of the incident, the unit had automatically shut down due to a problem in another part of the process. During this shutdown, the hydrogen and hydrocarbons flowing through the fired heater’s tubes stopped, but the burners continued operating because the fuel gas control valve did not fully close. Without fluid flow through the tubes to remove heat, the tube’s temperature exceeded 1,400℉ (), causing a short-term overheating and degrading tubes’ integrity. When the fired heater was restarted, one of the tubes ruptured.

The INITATING CAUSE was a failure of a fired heater tube due to overheating, due to the failure of a valve expected to stop the burners. The ROOT CAUSE was lack of proper knowledge/assessment of the process parameters (temperatures and flows) and consequent failing to optimise the process. High temperature on tubes had already been measured in the past but disregarded as fallacious. The high values were misinterpreted as indicative of the oxide layer formed at the external surface of the tube, rather than of the tube material. Therefore, the company failed to adjust the burner parameters to avoid temperature excess.