Explosion in a waste tank of a pharmaceutical plant
An explosion occurred around noon while conducting hot work (with a disc saw) on a 320-m³ fixed-roof tank at a pharmaceutical plant employing 240 personnel. The tank belongs to a waste treatment unit as part of an antibiotic production process. The tank cover was blasted 20 m away and the subcontractor performing cutting works was killed. Three other subcontractors and a plant employee were severely burnt and injured by the shock wave. Notified by neighbours and not by the operator, fire fighters arrived on the scene 15 min after the explosion and promptly extinguished the esulting fire. Municipal and provincial authorities as well as Regional Environmental Agency officials were duly informed of the accident; the operator issued two press releases.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
INITIATING CAUSE: Anaerobic fermentation of both the liquid phase and a solid deposit in the thank was responsible for generating explosive gases (especially hydrogen and methane). Sparks generated while the subcontractor was working adjacent to the air duct triggered the ignition and the explosion of the flammable mixture. The duct had been temporarily disconnected but not sealed. ROOT CAUSE: Under normal operations, the tank collected a liquid fermentation residue composed of water and micro-organisms assumed dead. The initial design included an air injection circuit at the tank bottom and a suction circuit at the level of its vent, in order to homogenise effluent. That system was shut down (10 years prior to the accident) - it was considered redundant as a mixing baffle had already been installed at the tank bottom - but this resulted in the formation of an anaerobic atmosphere Several deficiencies were observed regarding works organisation, namely: lack of precision in written procedures governing hot works and poor understanding of procedures among employees and subcontractors, plus inadequate subcontractor expertise (as demonstrated by failure to plug the duct).
