Explosion and fire on a compressor in a petrochemical plant
The explosion occurred in a benzene production unit (Litol process), which was being restarted following a scheduled shutdown for maintenance. About 30 kilograms of hydrogen gas were relesed into a compressor shed from a burst flange operating at 4. 8 MPa (700 psig). The following explosion caused two injuries and two fatalities. The investigation is reported in the referred scientific article, and arrived to these conclusions: 1. the hydrogen was released through a failed flange gasket. 2. it accumulated and ignited under the roof of the compressor shed. It also escaped from this semi-confined structure and accumulated under the roof of an adjacent building. 3. Probably the cloud under the roof of the compressor shed ignited first, and deflagrated to the rest of the cloud. 4. the total estimated cloud mass was 30 kg, however the force of the blast suggest a much higher energy. 5. This leak could not have been detected, because the leak test procedure use gas only up to 0. 7 MPa.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITIATING cause was the failure of a gasket on hydrogen compressor. Flange and gasket were of the correct type. Perhaps the gasket was displaced and/or the bold improperly tightened. According to reference MacDiarmit et al 1989, the real cause of the gasket failure could not be found, despite establishing that the gasket was not catered. This could have been caused by the use of a lubricant when installing the gasket, and the use of a gasket type not corresponding to the original specification (but which demonstrated good performance for many years). A ROOT CAUSE were unauthorised or improperly considered modifications, which clearly played a major role in this incident. There had been several modifications carried out in the Litol unit which were not adequately documented or for which documented authorization was not available. For example the installation of a valve drain and the addition of gables and a wall to the compressor shed originally consisting of only a roof over the compressors. The walls were likely added to aid in winter operation and maintenance, but hindered the dispersion of the gas. Additional ROOT or CONTRIBUTING CAUSE were (1) a risk assessment which did not consider the possibility of a full gasket failure, (2) a leak test procedure performed at a pressure value well below the operative pressure.
