Explosion and fire in a chemical plant producing aromatic hydrocarbon
The incident occurred at the hydro-dealkylation (HDA) plant of an aromatics manufacturer. The affected component was a heat exchanger part of the hydrogen purification system. This part failed releasing a gaseous mixture of hydrogen (H2), methane (CH4) and ethane (CH3-CH3) at 54 bar, causing an explosion followed by a fire. The heater used to regenerate the adsorbent beds of the purification unit had been repaired a few hours earlier, but the automatic heating mode had not been activated upon restart. Consequently, two regeneration cycles had been carried out cold, causing an overload of the adsorber and the fouling of the heat exchanger. The operators detected a pressure problem in the exchanger and shut down the installation. The explosions occurred 40 minutes later. The investigation showed that the seals and fins of the heat exchanger had been corroded by condensing aqueous components in the hydrogen purification gas flow. The facility had been in operation for 20 years.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITIATING CAUSE was the loss of containment caused by the failure of a component of a heat exchanger. A material analysis revealed that the only cause for containment failure was the corrosion on the fins and the soldering points, caused by small amounts of aqueous components and traces of acidic and basic components. As a result, during the 20 years of operation, weakened fins gradually broke off and eventually the self-supporting structure ruptured, tearing open the heat exchanger. Inspections of neighbouring parts of the system did not reveal any comparable corrosion damage. CONTRIBUTING CAUSE was the erroneous execution of two purification cycles after a repair. The ROOT CAUSE was the lack of a procedure for inspection, maintenance and repair.
