The various sources highlighting this case are cautious in drawing a root cause analysis. As in all incidents characterised by escalations and extensive fire(s), the identification of the root cause is hindered by the great damage to structures and equipment. It is very probable that the chamber failed by releasing hydrogen through the beam windows, however there were additional flammable materials and fuels in the chamber, contributing from the start other fire, including probably a gaseous hydrogen supply lone. The bubble chamber of this experiment was one of the first developed for the detection of charged elementary particles from experiments with accelerators. The accelerator laboratory had started only few years before, the first prototype of the bubble accelerator dated back to 1960. The chamber was starting operation on the day of the incident. It is not known which validation and qualification tests were performed before, nevertheless the chamber must be considered as a pioneering experimental equipment. A scientific article written in 1962 was recognising the difficulty of a sound safety-design: “The principal source of danger lies in malfunction or failure of equipment, releasing gas into the atmosphere with the formation of an explosive hydrogen-air mixture. Important safety considerations are: proper design of equipment and housing facilities, hydrogen control before, during and after bubble-chamber operation, and elimination of ignition sources. Design and operation are complicated by the lack of universal standards for handling liquid hydrogen and the use of conflicting procedures for controlling hydrogen hazards at various facilities. ” Weintralub, A. A. ; Weinstein, M. S. , Bubble Chambers, Health Physics 8(1):p 11-15
The bubble chamber body and vacuum box were equipped with beamport windows made of beryllium. Most probable cause was the failure of first the inner and then the outer beryllium ports which sealed the LH2 from the chamber insulating vacuum and the vacuum from atmosphere. Failure of the outer window was due to impact of inner window fragments and the sudden temperature shock caused from LH2. The material fractured in the brittle mode due to stresses induced by differential thermal contraction forces as well as by the internal pressure. Surface imperfections due to machine tool fabrication operations produced stress intensifiers high enough to cause ultimate failure.