Premature opening of a pressure relief valve
A CGH2 tube trailer was transferring hydrogen to a customer cylinder skid. The pressure relief on the customer system opened, the escaping hydrogen ignited and burned for approximately 10-15 seconds, causing a 30ft flame. This occurred at the end of the filling process, the gauge pressure was approaching 2400 psi (166 bar) and the driver was proceeding to terminate the process. The safety relief valve vented before the driver could complete the process. The driver received burns while trying to close valves. Safety relief valve was designed to activate at 2400 psig (166 bar).
Event Date
April 21, 2005
Record Quality Indicator
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences

The INITIATING CAUSE was the premature activation of a pressure relief valve. ROOT CAUSE could be attributed to a (i) defective component (the valve), or (ii) to a erroneous choice of the pressure value for the activation (erroneous design), or (ii) to the transfer procedure which was not allowing for uncertainty in the final pressure of the process (erroneous procedure). A human error cannot be excluded either.