Fire on a hydrogenation reactor of a refinery
A weld on a 1 inch diameter instrument tapping from a Octafiner reactor overhead line fractured, resulting in a small but intense fire, lasting about 50 minutes until the unit was nitrogen purged. The fire was always under control and the fire fighting effort was directed solely to cooling the surrounding metal with fire steam lances. Plant Inspection reported that the failure was due to hydrogen embrittlement of the heat affected zone of the tapping and probably resulted from improper or no stress relieving of the connection during construction.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Causes
Cause Comments
The INITIATING CAUSE was the failure of a weld on an instrument line of the reactor. The fracture was due to hydrogen embrittlement, probably worsened by the presence of non-design stress probably due to an inadequate heat treatment for relieving welding stress. The ROOT CAUSE could then be attributed to manufacturing shortcoming, possibly together with choice of non-optimal materials. Nothing is known on the inspection procedures which could identify degradation in its early stage.
