Fire in a ammonia production plant
The incident occurred at an ammonia production plant. The plant was starting, when a section of piping between the secondary reformer and a waste heat boiler (“transition pipe”) ruptured. Process gas was released and ignited. The ruptured transition pipe was a special piping component designed to contain process gas above 600 PSI (40 bar) at more than 1,600 degrees Fahrenheit (870 degrees centigrade). When the pipe ruptured, 4900 pounds (2. 2 metric tons) of hot process gas were released into the air and ignited by auto-ignition, resulting in a jet fire. The intense heat from the jet fire caused the transition piping to expand and rupture further culminating in a large fire. The composition of the process gas was a non-quantified mixture of hydrogen, nitrogen, methane, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide. The transition pipe comprised four layers: an inner metal liner, an insulation layer, and an outer metal shell, all surrounded by a metal jacket containing water to maintain a consistent temperature of the shell’s outer surface. The company’s investigation concluded that: (1) The initial failure resulted from creep damage due to prolonged exposure to stress at elevated temperatures along a circumferential weld in the transition pipe’s shell. A lack of post-weld heat treatment contributed to the transition pipe’s short life. (2) The larger failure of the transition pipe’s shell base metal resulted from short-term overheating from the initial jet fire. (3) Damage to the pipe insulation liner and to the insulation layer, as well as the water jacket operating (at times) with only a partially filled liquid level, all contributed to the higher shell operating temperatures that led to the creep damage.

The INITIATING CAUSE was cracking of the pipe due to creep. The ROOT CAUSE was low material quality, probably lack of proper post-treatment of a weld. CONTRIBUTING Factors to too high temperatures were some damages to the pipe and the partial inefficacy of its cooling system.