Explosion in a fertilisers plant
The vent occurred in the ammonia production unit. A minor leak had been detected in a flange on the piping of the ammonia synthesis loop (operating at 250 bar). The company called a specialized external contractor to perform an on-stream repair of the valve. This solution was chosen because of for the limited extents of the leakage and the economic costs and efforts associated to a shut-down of a very complex system. The on-stream repair consisted in: (1) fabrication of a special bracket in two parts adapted to the dimensions of the flange of the valve, and (2): injection of filling material in the bracket around the flange (the material had to be injected at a pressure higher than the operating pressure inside the pipe). During the repair some stud bolts broke causing the escape of a jet of a gaseous mixture of unknown amount of hydrogen and nitrogen at 250 bars. The escaping mixture exploded, killing 2 workers and damaging the valves and the piping.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
INITIATING cause was the failure of a flange followed by the release of a nitrogen-hydrogen mixture. The investigation revealed that two causes have probably contributed to the accident:(1): the flange stud-bolts of the valve have been replaced by others made of a material not equivalent to the one originally specified;(2): the maintenance company performing the repair have not taken into account the overpressure on the stud-bolts due to the injection of the filling material in the bracket. Therefore the root cause could be identified in the lack of a proper risk assessment of the repairing operation.
