Explosion and fire at a metal powder metallurgy plant.
The event occurred at one of the unit producing iron powder, consisting of a furnace with a running belt for the powder, kept under hydrogen atmosphere to reduce and purify the metal. The hydrogen was supplied to the furnace through a pipeline running in a trench below the furnace. A corroded section of this pipeline released hydrogen which could cumulated in the covered trench for at least 30’ before igniting. The following hydrogen explosion projected into the atmosphere a large quantity of iron dust, which also ignited. The consequences were three fatalities and additional two injured workers. DETAILED DESCRIPTION from the CSB REPORT (se references) Operators near one of the belt furnaces heard a hissing noise that they identified as a gas leak. The operators determined that the leak was in a trench, an area below the band furnaces that contains hydrogen, nitrogen, and cooling water runoff pipes, in addition to a vent pipe for the furnaces. The operators informed the maintenance department, and six mechanics were dispatched to find and repair the leak. Although maintenance personnel knew that hydrogen piping was in the same trench, they presumed that the leak was nitrogen because of a recent leak in a nitrogen pipe elsewhere in the plant and started removing trench covers by using an overhead crane. They determined that the leak was near a trench covers which the crane could not reach. Therefore they acquired a forklift and started removing that covers. During this operation a powerful explosion. A corroded section of piping carrying hydrogen was the cause of the hydrogen leak (the CSB investigation revealed a large hole of approximately 3 x 7 inches. The hydrogen was probably ignited by friction sparks produced when lifting the trench cover. The resulting explosion overpressure dispersed large quantities of iron dust from rafters and other surfaces in the upper reaches of the building. Portions of this dust subsequently ignited. Eyewitnesses reported embers raining down and igniting multiple dust flash fires in the area. According to the CSB report, it is difficult to attribute the final damages to one of the two fire sources. The consequences were three fatalities and additional two injured workers.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITATING CAUSE the hydrogen leak, cumulation and explosion from a pipe. This event escalated when the iron powder was involved in the following fire. The domino effect occurred becasue two independent hazards were present at the same time at the facility. IRON POWDER: iron powder is flammable and explosive. This was not correctly recognised by the operator of the facility. On top of that, two previous accidents in the same year caused by iron powder explosions and/or fires had made clear that iron dust was present everywhere in the facility, and not only limited to the production areas. This constituted an additional not recognised hazard. HYDROGEN The trench involved in the accident contained many pipes including nitrogen and hydrogen supply and vent pipes for the furnaces. In addition to housing pipes, the trench was also draining the cooling water used in the band furnaces. At the time of the accident, this water came out of the furnaces hot and drained directly onto the pipes and into the trench. Despite the availability of national codes dealing with this type of hazards, the facility operator had not in place any inspection/monitoring of the state of health of the pipelines. Slow corrosion could develop undetected for a long period. In addition, there were no procedure for mitigating leaks. The team looking for the leak could access the trench without checking presence of explosive mixture beforehand. It assumed a nitrogen leak based on a previous case, and did not raised the possibility of a hydrogen release. The ROOT CAUSE was a management failure in recongising the two hazards and the related high risks and in taking th erequired preventing measures. The fact that the leaking hydrogn could cumulate in the trench was also a safety design failure. The fact that iron powder was everywhere in the premises highlights shortcoming in cleaning procedures.
