Explosion at the toluene di-amide synthesis unit of a chemical plant
An explosion and fire occurred at night inside a unit for the synthesis of toluene di-amine. The process implied the hydrogenation of di-nitrotoluene in presence of isopropanol as solvent and Raney nickel as catalyst. Hydrogen and the other reacting components were injected into a reactor at high pressure. A run-away reaction occurred due to the mixing of too much reactive product into the reactor. This is an event where hydrogen was involved, but did not have the principal role. Internal fire-fighters had the blaze under control in 35 min. Four employees were hospitalised. The plant was destroyed. Glass panes shattered over a 50-100 m radius; the distillation unit adjoining the bunker was also damaged, causing the isopropanol and TDA to leak out, thus exacerbating the fire outbreak. Buildings at the neighbouring industrial site 150 m away were damaged.
Event Initiating System
Classification of the Physical Effects
Nature of the Consequences
Cause Comments
The INITIATING CAUSE was a runaway hydrogenation reaction due to the injection of too much reacting product into the reactor. The concentration of DNT in the reactor was insufficiently diluted. This allowed the development of a reaction reaching pressure and temperature beyond their design values. The injection of too much DNT was due to two partially open valves, allowing 500 to 700 kg/hr of product to flow into the reactor. The heat release from the hydrogenating a small quantity of DNT most likely triggered, through sudden heating of the reaction medium, the violent decomposition of the remaining DNT. The investigation discovered that risk analysis performed for this plant was inadequate. The ROOT CAUSE is related to an inadequate safety-design and to the failure of the management to recognise the hazards during operation.
