Hydrogen Jet Flame Impingement Panels/Barriers
We have put panels with non-isolatable fittings mounted very near to some h2 tanks. The panels are suppose to be deflection panels to avoid direct and sustained flame impingement on the tanks. I have recently learned that these panels are made of 1/8" and 1/2" thick aluminum. I am 100% not comfortable about the 1/8" Al panel and so we are addressing this by adding a 1/4" steel panel to the backside, but the 1/2" aluminum panel?? TBH I'm not comfortable with this either. I have heard anecdotally from a tprd testing lab that their 1/2" steel plate has worked for years in blocking h2 jets from tprd releases, and, that 'fairly' thick Al straps have dissolved very quickly, in these tests. Therefore 1/4" steel panels should last 'enough' time for responders to get there and setup a water spray on the tanks to keep them cool. If you have received any information or recommendations I would be very interested, or if you could recommend any contacts I could reach out to maybe within the CHS membership.
Agree that it's somewhat surprising that there isn't more research on flame impingement barriers. The Fire Codes are focused on fire resistance ratings, as opposed to impingement. Whereas these are important for building protection, and they offer some basis for reference, they don't necessarily address impingement issues which can be important and more pertinent for equipment.
Using metal barriers to provide protection and reduce risk from fires is favorable. A fire barrier wall would also do this, but there are times where they simply aren't practical or necessary. Preventing fire impingement onto equipment, particularly vessels, can result in significant reduction in risk. Direct impingement of a jet fire on pressurized equipment can easily lead to failure since the material gets hot and can weaken rapidly while it's highly stressed. Providing an impingement barrier can significantly delay or prevent a hazard by greatly lessening the temperature of the exposed equipment.
In many incidents and designs seen, even fairly thin (11 gauge) carbon steel has held up very well during jet fires. There might be some mild distortion from the heat, but burn-through or failure of the steel, even for what appear to be very intense fires was not observed. Equipment behind those barriers certainly gets hot, but generally not enough to fail. The steel holds up well since there is basically no stress on the impingement barrier the way there might be on pressurized equipment or structural elements. Probably 1/4" steel would offer most systems significant protection based on observations, but the design should carefully consider both structural and fire resistance for the specific application.
Aluminum should NOT be used. Aluminum, especially when less than 1/4" has been shown to readily melt in hydrogen fires. While a nominal hydrogen fire should melt carbon steel, that has not been seen in numerous incidents. Sometimes no distortions were observed. Based on several past test campaigns, if barrier strength is a concern consider using stainless steel or diamond plate (which is stiffer than regular carbon steel plate).
A few other considerations to keep in mind are that steel fire deflection barriers can be upgraded to a fire barrier fairly easily. Maybe not to a 2 hours fire barrier, but to something that would last longer than a plate, and would allow time for the fire department to add water for cooling. Also, be sure these fire deflection barriers do not create confinement or congestion, increasing the probability of ignition and the possibility of a deflagration/explosion.
Impingement barriers are under appreciated and not addressed in codes the way they could or should be. However, there has been some testing that may be helpful provided below.
a. Sandia National Lab was involved in a paper - Analysis of jet flames and unignited jets from unintended releases of hydrogen – ScienceDirect https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0360319909001207
b. Some work was done by Hysafe on this topic @ https://hysafe.info/uploads/papers/2023/139.pdf
